Southern Marsh Orchids

Southern Marsh Orchids

Friday 8 August 2014

Spotted crane fly at Forest Farm

Lunchtime stroll around Forest Farm today and stumbled across these - almost stepped on the crane fly!
Having never seen one of these before, I have been scanning images on the internet and now assume it to be a Spotted Crane fly.


Further down the path I spotted this, which following the same process as above I assume to be a Scorpion Fly. It flew away before I had a chance to grab any other shots.

I would be grateful for confirmation of these IDs. Amazing what you can find when you're not looking for them!

Howard

10 comments:

  1. I would suggest you are correct on both counts - Spotted Cranefly, Nephrotoma appendiculata and Scorpion Fly most likley Panorpa communis

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks tomcat. I've looked these up and they do seem to fit the bill nicely.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What makes you say it the Scorpion fly is communis rather than germanica? I thought it was almost impossible to separate the females of these species. I would also be interested to know how you get to Nephrotoma appendiculata without a side view of the thorax.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Dave. As you know I tend to base my IDs on visual appearance and image comparison and I have to admit that I opted for communis on the basis that I thought the spots on the wings were a better match for this species than for germanica.

      Howard

      Delete
    2. Colin Plant's key to Scorpion Flies implies that the wing markings are too variable to be diagnostic. Keys can of course be wrong!

      Delete
  4. In fact having keyed it out, I'm pretty sure the Cranefly is Nephrotoma flavipalpis - the combination of dark stigma and the colour of the head being diagnostic.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ok you've got me on that one! I hadn't noticed the dark stigma against the ground colour, but I still wouldn't say that the head colour is the 'diagnostic' yellow. However, I concede the extent of the colour is more extensive than that shown in images for appendiculata and so, on reflection, I agree that flavipalpis is a better match.

      Howard

      Delete
    2. The head isn't black, which it would be on the other species with a black stigma!

      Delete
    3. agreed flavipalps Female Scorps cant be done in the field http://www.ukwildlife.net/insects/mecoptera/panorpa_communis.html

      Delete
  5. Yes the 'diagnostic' yellow used to ID this species in the key for Nephrotoma is a bit misleading, as it's really more of a reddish orange. I've seen a few this week and all have had the same head colour as Howard's specimen.

    ReplyDelete